The Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) quashed a ₹1.49 crore penalty that the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX) had imposed on Ventura Securities. The tribunal criticized MCX, which functions as a first-line regulator, for what it called a “third-rate process,” citing significant procedural flaws.
The penalty followed a client’s breach of position limits in 2024. SAT found it was nearly 75 times the ₹2 lakh maximum prescribed by a SEBI circular.
The order also noted that the penalty carried the signature of a committee member whose tenure had ended six months earlier. MCX described this as a “bona fide error.”
SAT ordered MCX to refund the entire amount collected, including GST, and pay Ventura Securities ₹1 lakh in costs. The ruling is a notable reputational setback for the exchange.